[clue-talk] The War On...?
Sean LeBlanc
seanleblanc at comcast.net
Thu Dec 30 13:50:26 MST 2004
On 12-30 10:24, Don Collier wrote:
> You are missing the point of what I had said. My point is that we DO have
> to obey the laws that we feel are unjust while we try to get those laws
> changed. Getting arrested for a cause means nothing at all. It is a
> personal statement and bears no weight in getting that law changed. Not
> to mention the fact that you are now in jail and have limited resources to
> fight the fight.
>
> Joe "Zonker" Brockmeier wrote:
>
> On Wed, 29 Dec 2004 13:56:50 -0700, Don Collier
> [1]<dcollier at collierclan.com> wrote:
>
>
> In my opinion, every American has a duty to obey the law now matter how
> unjust that we feel it is. There are ways to make your voice heard other
> than breaking the law. We cant pick and choose which laws that we wish to
> obey.
>
>
> What if a law passed by Congress or state legislature contradicts with
> the Constitution? Or with a person's religion?
>
> I heartily disagree with this -- people have a duty to do the "right
> thing," and if that conflicts with the law, so be it. (Obviously,
> people will disagree on what the "right thing" is...)
>
> For example -- sections of the Patriot Act that give the government
> additional powers to spy on library patrons. I won't hold it against a
> librarian who follows the law, but I think it's a far better thing for
> a librarian to refuse to comply with the law in protest.
>
> We'd be in a sorry (sorrier?) state if Americans had always decided to
> "obey the law, no matter how unjust" -- come to think of it, we'd
> probably still be English subjects if that were the case.
>
> Best,
>
> Zonker
>
>
> --
Wow. The above is extremely hard to read. Is your reader stripping out the
standard >'s as well as the attributions or something? I only ask because in
Mutt I have to read and re-read to see who is saying what. The top-posting
doesn't help, but that's nothing compared to having everything else crammed
together with no indentation, no >'s, and no attribution.
--
Sean LeBlanc:seanleblanc at comcast.net
Adversity has the effect of eliciting talents, which in prosperous
circumstances would have lain dormant.
-Horace
More information about the clue-talk
mailing list